back to TOPSPURS homepage

 

 

 

6th June 2007 - Transfer Targets or Transfer Strategy?

 

I was browsing through some of the posts featured in News Now and was surprised to see so much of our fan’s transfer speculation focused on left wingers; who we should get, who we can get, and worst of all, what dire consequences there will be if we don’t get anybody.

 

My understanding is that the transfer window for summer is not even officially open until 1 July (after the internationals and the finish of some leagues in Europe still playing) but even ignoring this, it seems far too myopic to be worrying about a position that has so few options of ‘available’ talent. Not only this, but I asked myself why there are so few options to choose from. It’s easy to get caught up in this left winger syndrome, but seriously, there are very few clubs that play with a dedicated left winger, and if they do, it is unlikely that they have a matching winger on the other flank. So why is it so important for Spurs to try and find a mirror image of Mr A Lennon who can run down the touchline on the left?

 

In fact, how often does our above mentioned right winger run down the touchline, like a winger?

 

The real deal is that we do not have a dedicated midfield player who is disciplined and comfortable enough to control the left hand side of the pitch, track back and help the full back and chuck over a few out-swinging crosses with his left peg.

I have a feeling that’s why we have invested so much money in young Mr Bale.

 

Our Cameroonian and South Korean full backs can do a good job in this left sided position. Mr Asso-Ekotto will be better next season, and before his injury, Mr Lee was showing that experience and tenacity make for a big contribution to a team. If they could rely on a skilful left footer, who knows how to tackle and track back, to always be available just ahead of them, the team’s exposure to goalmouth damage from right midfield crosses from the opposition would be greatly reduced. Oh and if , like this season, we have too many injuries to this full back position, we also have ready made cover instead of trying to play Mr Tainio or Mr Chimbonda or Mr Gardener so obviously out of position at left back that it was frightening as well as embarrassing.

 

If the ‘more sober’ press reports are to be believed, we do however seem to have almost done some excellent business in securing the Auxerre want-away centre back.

 

Lack of quality cover for Mr King cost us enormously last season, so this is excellent news that we may now have four experienced, quality center backs (and Mr Gardener) should we become similarly afflicted by injuries in this defensive position next season.

 

So far, so good for Messrs Commoli and Jol with the transfer strategy.

 

But some more is needed.

 

Appropriate cover for Mr Chimbonda as Mr Stalteri still looks too wooden in this position and does not offer any other covering options.

. .

When you play with us at MANSION.com a portion of the profit goes to support Tottenham Hotspur Football Club

 

Cool, Calm, Collectable - Spurs poker chips

 

 

A replacement for Mr Mido, in case (perish the thought) Mr Berbatov becomes unfit to play for any long period of time.

 

Then one more ‘star’ signing. A central midfielder with the skill, determination and presence for Tottenham that was built into the characters of Stevie Perryman, Graham Roberts, Dave McKay, Alan Mullery, Gary Mabbutt and of course Danny Blanchflower. Unfortunately, I do not think such a player exists  - maybe Makalele at Chel$ki, Scholes at ManUre and Gerrard at LiveintheUSApool are the best current playing examples in the Premier League - but there must be others somewhere who would be prepared to play with their heart on their sleeve for the great THFC?

 

Targets or Strategy? For me the latter works better; so I hope our management can keep focused on this and not start bouncing around a target list of YouTube wanabees for some unknown or overpriced player who can kick a ball with his left foot.

 

 

 

Columnist Profile – The Guest Column

The Guest column is open for any genuine Spurs fan (or anyone with something interesting to write about Spurs) – all you have to do is write yer piece, sling it to the site editor: nicolaberti at topspurs d0t com      and it’ll be on here soon after, and distributed amongst Spurs supporters the world over via the newsnow news service

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

MANSION

 

..          ..


Click for the latest THFC news on NEWSNOW


A full range of THFC merchandice from the TOPSPURS shop



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1st June - Spurs in Hong Kong by Eric Mallia www.spursinhongkong.com

A great weekend was had by all.  The boys and Clive Allen took time out to hang out with us on Sunday after they were knocked out in Qfinals by some very dodgy referring.  They appreciated the support.  Probably about 40 Spurs there in total - mainly expats, locals and some Oz Spurs.  Easily the best supported team at the tournament.  The Arse got knocked out in the Qfinals too and we had a good laugh at them.  Needless to say, they had no support except from a few plastic locals who would have no idea where Scumbury is let alone London.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOn8eziQY4c

On the playing side, Forecast in goal looks good but could do with eating a few big meals.  Leigh Mills looks the part as does Barcham.  Ifil was solid as was O'Hara.  Daniels is an Anthony Gardner clone (and not much better).  Archibald-Henville looks like the Honey Munster.

Little known fact.  O'Hara got shown the red card after the final whistle, so disgusted at the dodgy penalty decision awarded to the token HK team.  At least it showed they cared. 

More photos here... http://www.flickr.com/photos/8503494@N02/sets/72157600268796836

All told, a thoroughly enjoyable (and drunken) weekend.

Click here if you are a Spurs supporter in Hong Kong or have an interest in what Spurs supporters in Hong Kong are up to - http://www.spursinhongkong.com

Eric

PS. Aston Villa won it versus CC Mariners from Australia.
PPS.  Matt Le Tissier is very fat and John Barnes fatter still 

 

 

21st May 2007 - Time comparison from David Geaves

I have been a Spurs supporter since 1959, 12 years old then, my Dad was getting excited about them and the way they playing  then next season the Double, and Bob's Your Uncle, I was hooked for life.

 

In those days Spurs were a class act, world class players all over the place with the indomitable Dave McKay in the middle of the park. Jimmy Greaves was my boyhood hero and still is, he's still the best goalscorer I have ever seen.

 

Sadly those days were not to last and it was not until Keith Burkinshaw came along that some glory came to the club. I always felt he was under-rated at the time and I rate him second only to Bill Nicholson; shame he left when he did but he could see the writing on the wall when Irvin Scholar took over.

 

Then all the years of turmoil followed but now there is a new dawn with Levy, Jol and Comolli at the helm and I feel that now we are going places but we must be patient, a hard thing for Spurs supporters to be but we must, rebuilding ourselves to challenge the top 4 will take another season or two yet. Should we buy new players then it may take a season to bed in, al la Zokora, so maybe not next season but the one after.

 

I hope the management team stays in place for a long time, players like coming to Spurs, it's a happy club who follow the tradition of playing good football and where youngsters who are good enough get a chance. We also have that English contingent which makes me proud I support Spurs and not Liverpool or Arsenal. I hate to say it but Foreign Club Arsenals football was wonderful to watch a couple of years back but nary an englishman in sight, or very rarely and almost the same with Real Liverpool.

 

Dimitar Berbatov, what a player, lovely bloke too (not in a gay way!), he has been likened to Alan Gilzean and there is a similarity, Gilzean was a better header of the ball, but Berbatov with his flicks, awareness and goalscoring prowess really does bode well for the future and his partnership with Keane/Defoe. Shades of Greaves and Gilzean, those two will be impressed by our new forward line I am sure.

 

What of the future, our left side needs sorting out, I would love Morten Gamst Pedersen to be in our side, reminds me of Tony Galvin, but Pedersen has a better goalscoring pedigree. I would break the bank for him. But what I think we really need is an old head midfield general, someone like Gatusso of AC Milan, we need direction in the midfield, someone who sits in front of the defence and destroys the opposition attacks and spurs on the rest of the team, we need a real fighter in there to harden up our soft centre.

 

So, thank you for giving me the opportunity to write my piece, long live Martin Jol, he has given us our pride back again, soon we will be one of the top 4, of that I am sure so be patient Spurs supporters, Glory is coming again to White Hot Lane!

Best wishes

 

Dave

 

May 18th 2007 - Parallels between two ‘sleeping giants’ (beginning with ‘S’)… from Paul Franklyn

Firstly, I should explain this is just a bit of fun, not to be taken too seriously.  It just suddenly occurred to me the other day in a boring meeting at work.

 

About two years ago I was employed by a large UK Supermarket (in fact in overall retail terms they are a monster).  Let’s call them, ‘Retailer S’.

 

I sometimes wonder what drew me to work here.  There’s certainly a reason to wonder too, as I’m sure at the time of employment there weren’t too many positive reasons to join!

 

Then I considered the following…:

 

Retailer S used to be leading the way in it’s market esp. in the 60s-80s period

Retailer S was badly mismanaged throughout the 90s

Retailer S has lost so much ground to its main rival that it once dominated.  A rival that has gone on to flourish in the UK & Europe and built new, larger property to increase revenues & profit.

Retailer S has even been surpassed by another rival who have received massive investment from a foreign counterpart in the last few years.  Previously this rival had few customers, but now seem to have lots who have come out of the woodwork!

Retailer S have not had much European interest in recent times

Retailer S has an extremely loyal customer base

Retailer S have historically charged their loyal customers higher prices than their rivals for no additional quality

Retailer S has had a few false dawns over the last 5 years

Retailer S is at threat from a takeover - partly due to a recent upturn in fortunes, partly because it’s property portfolio is so valuable

Retailer S has a King at the helm.

 

….And then realised why I work here!

 

COY ‘Retailer S’!!

 

 

11th May 2007 - Another summer of disappointment? (Andy M)

Firstly I suppose I should give you a bit of background about me. I've had a season ticket at Spurs for 26 years, my favourite memories are the magic moments, Ricky at Highbury and Wembley, the Gascoigne double at Portsmouth, Hoddle teaching the master Cruyff at WHL , Klinsmann's winner at Anfield etc.. The typical 'spurs' moments.

I've lived and breathed it for all these years and normally the expense and time could always be justified by getting something back, the odd final, the odd coup in the transfer market, a few big wins against the big teams (the magic moments).  However the years have taken their toll and I just feel I am not getting enough back these days, one semi against Chelsea  and a league cup where none of the big boys fielded a side in the last decade is a poor return on any investment.

I'm fed up of getting shat on by the plc, I am sure that if we had made the UEFA Final I'd be drawing for a ticket out of a ballot just like some Liverpool fans are having to do and my seat would no doubt have been wasted on a champagne drinking non spurs fan.  I'm embarrassed that my club brings out a DVD of us beating Chelsea at home days after a win, surely our ambitions are slightly higher than that.

Last night, for the first time ever, I couldn't be bothered to go to Spurs. 

I didn't even watch it on the box, I am just fed up of being let down.

My argument is this, we have known what we have had to do to compete with the top 4 for 2 seasons now and we have not done it. It is quite simple, strengthen the areas of the squad that don't have the quality.  We have the finance (18 million from Carrick plus merchandise, all these hikes in prices etc..), but we play these cat and mouse tactics, drag out the whole scenario and lose out or make a panic buy.

I was furious at the start of last season when I heard people were happy with our dealings.  Granted Berbatov and Zokora were good, but there is no point doing half a job.  We have needed a quality left back and left midfielder for a long time, certainly since Jol was in charge and the problem is still not sorted.  Without them, we will not challenge the top 4, end of story.

There's no point sniffing around Downing or Duff and then saying we tried.  We have to select a quality target and pay the money required.  We did it for Chimbonda, we must now do it for a left back.  Then a left midfielder, an aggressive central midfield player, cover for Ledley and a big man to cover Berba (if he stays).  If I was him I would want these signings guaranteed before I decided to stay and I hope he does this.  No doubt the board will paint him as a greedy foreigner who had his head turned but that is crap, a player of his quality needs to play at the top and if we aren't going to get there, he needs to move on.

Without these 5 quality signings we just ain't gonna compete and I can't handle another season where we beat the crap and then lose to the first decent team we play. If you're not going to be competitive, what is the point?

We have paid the cash for years, we have sat through Atouba, Konchesky and Sinton and still the prices go up. It is now time for spurs to deliver.  If the club is not able to attract the top players, it should refund the season ticket increase that it has asked for to get them.

If they don't sort it out I am off. No more hard luck stories, you've got the cash, you've had the time, put up or shut up. Maybe some readers will say good riddance, 'you don't support the team' but I'm fed up with this plc inspired bullshit.  The board and spurs must deliver this summer or accept that 5th place and a decent cup run are all we are ever going to achieve. 

If it is the latter, I can't understand the attraction of going to Spurs anymore.

 

Andy M

 

1 May 2007 - Another piece about The Spurs management,

Nathan Flint adds his thoughts to the Spurs manager debate

Ok, ok, so you're all probably not relishing the thought of reading another piece on the Martin Jol debate. But please, hear me out, as I have just read an article written by Chris Biggs. Obviously, this piece has angered me as I feel compelled to write this immediately afterwards.

"If we need to get up to the upper echeleon, we need a new manager" - Chris Biggs

Please, please, please explain why in the world would anyone want to discard of a manager who is about to cement our status as the 5th best team in England? The comparisons Mr Biggs have made bear no relevance. He says we are comparing Jol to mediocrity - sorry Chris but I don't know what you've been watching for the last 10-15 years. The fact remains that we have been a mediocre team at best for as long as I can remember (I'm 21) and now we have players like Lennon, Berbatov, Dawson, Chimbonda - all top class and all brought in by Jol. Makes a change from Dumitrescu, Armstrong, Dominguez and defenders like Edinburgh and Austin, doesn't it?

The fact is, and I invite anyone to challenge this - Spurs are currently a team with massive potential to break the top 4 and realistically probably the only team from the rest of the Premiership able to achieve it. Tottenham Hotspur, under Martin Jol, have finished 9th, 5th, and I am confidently going to predict 5th again. Therefore that equals no bottom half finishes. Where were we when Santini left? 11th. And this is a man was judged to have the ability to manage the French national team. As a kid the best I could hope for at the end of the season was top of the bottom half and maybe a cup run. Now, under Jol, we still have an interest right up until the final game and something to play for. And we competed in three cup competitions this year, getting knocked out in the Quarter finals twice, and THAT semi-final.

 

Progression is being made, and there are always obstacles along the way. Last season it was Carrick leaving - this year could it be Berbatov or Lennon? If MJ can keep these players, sign two or three more of the same calibre and finally fill THAT left side, and not only with a world class player but some good backup, then for me next season you will see Spurs occupying 3rd-5th for most of the season. I think CL qualification is next season's priority, and if Big MJ fails this challenge, then, and only then, it is time to start asking questions.

 

Half time last Saturday in the NLD….

 Arsenal dressing room:

Wenger - "Right listen closely this is what we will do. Tottenham will try and defend their lead and hang on for one nil, [suppressing a laugh] they try this every year. Their CBs will camp out on the edge of their penalty area, they already started this behaviour as soon as they scored. We now have 3 in central midfield versus their two so Diaby and Gilberto, push on and occupy Jenas and Zokora. That combined with their defence dropping too deep will allow Fabregas the freedom of the pitch and allow him to run the midfield. Eboue and
Clichy, you two can push on and occupy their wide midfielders, Fabregas will always find you when he has time on the ball. Lennon is no threat on the left and has been told not to leave Rocha unprotected anyway. Tainio will leave his position on the right to try and help out in the centre once they realise they are overrun. Our CBs can push right up as neither Berbatov or Keane are quicker than Toure. And remember, you are all fitter than them and they will tire."

Arsenal Players - "Yes boss."



Tottenham dressing room:

Jeans - "Cracking goal Robbie."
Keane - "Thanks mate."
Lennon - "Who's up for clubbing tonight?."
Jenas - "I'm in."
Jol - "Hey, settle down lads. Listen to me. We can win this 1-0."
Berbatov - "But we never keep a clean sheet, surely we must look for the second goal?"
Jol - "Don't worry, I know what I am doing. We can still score a second from a set piece."
Berbatov - "But we never score goals from set pieces and we already got lucky from one once today. We don't even practise them."
Jol - "Don't worry Berbatov, I know what I am doing. Now, Lennon, you're having a great game. Eboue hasn't had a run at Rocha once yet. Keep doing whatever it is you're doing out there on the left."
Berbatov - "But he hasn't done anything? Not one dribble, not one shot, not one cross. He should play on the right."
Jol - "Don't worry Berbatov, I know what I am doing. Now, Jenas and Zokora, great game, you dominated the midfield first half."
Zokora - "But they brought Fabregas on, they have an extra man, we need help."
Jol - "Don't worry, Tainio will come inside and help out, and Robbie will try and stop the ball getting to Fabregas."
Berbatov - "That plan didn't work in the two cup games against them did it?"
Jol - "Don't worry, I know what I am doing. Anything to add Chris?"
Hughton - "Yeah, I've drawn a really nice picture of you boss."
Jol - "That is great work little man".

 

(with thanks to Glen who sent this to me and its original creator)

 

25th April 2007 – Chris Biggs furthers the case against Martin Jol

In response to Midnightjester’s article on Jester's article which attempted to provide a defence of Jol’s performance as manager and was in turn, written in response to my article The case against Martin Jol.

 

Transfers

 

One of the first issues Midnightjester raises is that of transfers in which he points out that Jol only has a net spend of £4m This though is distorted by the sale of Carrick. Furthermore, the net amount spent is not wholly representative of the finances at a club’s disposal. For instance, if Sheffield United spent £6m on players and recouped £2m would you really argue that they had a similar purchasing power to a club that can afford to spend £10.9m on one player?

 

Instead of ‘Jol has done more with less than any other manager’ it should have read

 

‘Jol has done more with more than any other manager’

 

Comparison with other managers

 

Midnighthester says that at this point only Alex Ferguson and Arsene Wenger are better quality coaches/managers than Jol. This seemingly ignores the fact that Mourinho won the European Cup with Porto, a club of similar standing to Spurs; Coppell has guided Reading to the top ten of the premiership whilst barely spending anything and Allardyce has made Bolton a regular top eight club despite their lack of spending and any decent players. Based on the resources available to them all have done a better job than Jol.

 

In relation to the other recent Spurs managers, Jol’s point per game record is a clear improvement but one must bear in mind the level being compared to:

 

Graham was a dinosaur

Hoddle thought it wise to pack his team with over 30s and had Pleat scheming behind his back.

Pleat and Hughton were a joke.

 

You are comparing to mediocrity.

 

Tactics

 

Midnightjester also says that Jol has recently stopped withdrawing the attacking end of our team early and has worked that the best form of defence is attack. This ignores the fact that we were 3-1 up at Chelsea and sat back, instead of killing them off (Admittedly when you are playing the Champions on their home turf one can see the thinking behind ‘what we have, we hold’ but Spurs simply don’t have the players to perform this way). Another example comes from the West Ham game where we came back from 2-0 down to draw level only to sit back again and let them regain the initiative. Finally, there were the damning events of Saturday where after taking control of the game, we deservedly took the lead only to sit back and let Arsenal destroy us. We only had one shot in the whole of the second half and Jol’s response? To take off our most dangerous midfielder. This was not the first time they have overrun u